Benni McCarthy has responded to criticism of his Harambee Stars squad selection and tactics following Kenya’s two AFCON 2027 qualifying matches against South Africa. After the 2–1 defeat in Nairobi on 17 November 2026, the Kenya head coach dismissed suggestions that public criticism would distract him from his work.
The response followed growing debate about which players McCarthy has called up, how he sets up his team and the results Kenya has produced. The former South Africa striker had already defended his selection approach before the return match, saying he chooses players according to what the team needs against each opponent.

What Benni McCarthy said about criticism after Kenya’s defeat
McCarthy’s post-match response focused on how he deals with criticism rather than on an appeal for supporters to lower their expectations. Speaking after Kenya lost to South Africa at Nyayo National Stadium, he said that criticism from outside his immediate working environment did not keep him awake at night.
“I sleep like a baby,” he said, while stressing that he would continue doing his job with the players and technical staff. His remarks attracted further scrutiny, particularly because of comments he made about the circumstances of some critics.
The controversy centres on both the team’s results and the tone of the coach’s response. It is important to distinguish what McCarthy actually said after the game from his earlier explanations of why certain players make his squad.
How McCarthy explained his Harambee Stars squad selections

Before the second South Africa match, McCarthy rejected accusations of favouritism and said his decisions depend on the opponent and the requirements of a particular game. That stance followed questions about players who had been included or left out of the November squad.
His 24-player final Harambee Stars squad followed an earlier 36-player provisional selection. The changes between those lists became part of the discussion around his choices.
Calls for in-form players also added to the debate. The push for Alpha Onyango’s Harambee Stars inclusion was one example of the competing views surrounding the squad. Separately, McCarthy had discussed potential opportunities for Emerging Stars players as Kenya plans for the 2027 tournament.
Kenya’s results against South Africa in November 2026
Kenya took one point from its two meetings with South Africa in November 2026. Harambee Stars drew 2–2 in Johannesburg on 13 November before losing 2–1 in Nairobi four days later.
| Date | Match | Final score |
| 13 November 2026 | South Africa vs Kenya | 2–2 |
| 17 November 2026 | Kenya vs South Africa | 1–2 |
The home defeat was decided by two Relebohile Mofokeng goals, with Mohammed Bajaber scoring late for Kenya. The Kenya–South Africa return-leg coverage provides the fixture background, while SportPesa Score offers a broader destination for football fixtures and results.
What the selection debate means for Kenya’s AFCON 2027 preparations

Kenya has already secured a place at the 2027 Africa Cup of Nations as one of the co-hosts alongside Tanzania and Uganda. The November qualifiers therefore remained meaningful competitive tests without determining whether Harambee Stars would reach the final tournament.
McCarthy’s task extends beyond the immediate results: he must assess who can contribute to the squad, how those players work together and which improvements are needed before the tournament. The Kenya AFCON 2027 qualification guide explains the Group D context and the co-host qualification arrangement.
The criticism has also highlighted a distinction between selection decisions and performances on the pitch. Strong club form may support a player’s case, but national-team choices also depend on roles, availability and the way the coach intends to approach an opponent. Whether those decisions produce better results remains a question for the matches ahead.
Benni McCarthy and the Harambee Stars road to AFCON 2027
Benni McCarthy’s comments after the South Africa matches have kept attention on his Harambee Stars selections, the team’s results and his relationship with critics. Kenya’s automatic AFCON 2027 qualification gives the technical staff a place at the finals, but not an exemption from scrutiny over preparation and performance.
Follow Harambee Stars squad updates for subsequent selection developments as the team prepares for its next international fixtures.


